BL

Operating asset

Black Thunder

CNR Production USA open_pit 100% owned
Valuation case2026-10-19
2026E saleable coal45 Mtprb thermal coal · literal product tonnes
ROM / CHPP feed45 Mt4× strip ratio
CHPP / saleable yield100%Saleable tonnes ÷ ROM feed
Realised coal price$14.27/tModeled pricing point
Site cash cost$13.73/tPer saleable tonne
Cash margin$0.54/tAfter royalties and modeled deductions
Risked NPV$-233m100% ownership

Investment verdict

One of the world's most productive surface mines, but with structurally thin PRB margins

B+
  • B+
    Grade & continuity

    331.5M reserve tons lie in a broad, predictable Wyodak-Anderson coal zone, though value per ton is low and price-sensitive.

  • A
    Metallurgy

    Coal is mined and conveyed directly through mature material-handling systems with no complex metallurgical recovery circuit.

  • B+
    Mining complexity

    Dragline and truck-shovel methods are conventional at scale, but multiple pits, highway/rail relocation and long haul distances create sequencing demands.

  • A
    Infrastructure & power

    Decades of established draglines, conveyors and multiple rail loadouts support very high annual volumes.

  • B+
    Permitting status

    The operation is mature and permitted, but its large reclamation footprint and bonding requirements remain material through closure.

  • A
    Resource confidence

    The February 2026 S-K 1300 report discloses 331.5M reserve tons and a complete 2026-2038 saleable production schedule.

  • B
    Geological upside

    205M measured-plus-indicated tons exclusive of reserves provide inventory, but conversion depends on low-margin economics and customer demand.

  • C
    Expansion optionality

    The mine can flex volume, yet its reserve plan declines sharply after 2030 and the TRS base case earns only US$1.20/t EBITDA.

Valuation snapshot

100% NAV retained
Unrisked NPV $-233m

Project DCF before the published stage and execution-risk charge.

Risk charge −$0m

Value removed by the model's project-stage and execution-risk adjustment.

Risked NPV $-233m

Selected project value after risk, before ownership attribution.

Effective discount rate 7%

Time-value hurdle used for the project DCF after published adjustments.

NPV at first production $-233m

Production-value anchor with pre-production timing removed; used by the FSV ladder.

Annual operating profile

Spot · risked · 100% of project
Saleable coal and CHPP yieldannual ROM-to-product conversion
Mt · %
Saleable-tonne economics2026E operating row and life-of-mine cost basis
US$/t
Realised price$14.27/t
Site cash cost$14.43/t
Cash cost incl. sustaining$14.68/t
Cash margin$0.54/t
ROM coal331.5 Mt
Saleable coal331.5 Mt
LOM saleable yield100%
Site cost / ROM t$14.43/t

A 100% yield indicates a schedule already expressed in saleable tonnes.

Revenue and cost stackcosts and capital aligned below zero
US$m
Capital recoveryannual and cumulative project cash flow
US$m

Timeline Built from the stored anchor years: construction start, first production, and closure (or first production plus reserve life where no closure year is published). The marker is the year the current valuation is struck from.

Construction
1977–2026
Production
2026–2039
19771985199320012009201720252033

Dashed line marks 2026, the year this valuation is struck from.

Resources and reserves

Effective 31 Dec 2025 · Attributable basis

Ore reserves

AssetProven (Mt)Probable (Mt)Proven & probable (Mt)
Black Thunder Mine 330 2.00 332

Mineral resources

AssetMeasured (Mt)Indicated (Mt)Measured & indicated (Mt)
Black Thunder Mine 200 5.00 205

Coal tonnes are on the disclosed source basis; no equivalent conversion is applied.

Valuation framework Fair speculative value ladder Production →
Two valuation lenses $-233m production-value OV anchors the speculative ladder; $-233m stage-risked DCF is the selected modeled project value.

Speculative value by development stage

Current model stage Production 100%–100% certainty
Market-implied project value $4,508m Company market capitalization
USD OV NPV—At production value
Diluted49.9mCompany shares F.D.
Net interest100%Attributable ownership
Exchange rate1.0000USD framework
The selected model does not have a positive production-value NPV, so a speculative-value range would be misleading.
Project stage Certainty FSV range Attributable FSV USD / share
01 Grassroots
0.5%–1%
—
—
—
02 Target Drilling
1%–2.5%
—
—
—
03 Discovery Delineation
2.5%–5%
—
—
—
04 Infill & Metallurgy
5%–10%
—
—
—
05 PEA
10%–25%
—
—
—
06 Prefeasibility
25%–50%
—
—
—
07 Permitting & Feasibility
50%–75%
—
—
—
08 Construction
75%–100%
—
—
—
09 Production Current
100%
—
—
—
Formula OV NPV × stage certainty × net interest ÷ diluted shares. Red marker = company market capitalization.